Will Cash Soon Be Obsolete?

Calls for the US to adopt a central bank digital currency (CBDC) appear to be growing. China launched a digital renminbi in April, leading many to worry that the US is falling behind. Other countries will no doubt follow.

Arguments in support of CBDCs often relate to cash, since the former would function as an alternative to the latter. For example, many point out that CBDCs would provide a digital alternative for the unbanked, who rely on cash to make transactions. A CBDC, they argue, would enable those left behind by the private sector to finally reap the rewards of financial inclusion. They do not seem to appreciate that many among the unbanked simply prefer to use cash. The FDIC reports that, “among unbanked households in 2019, more than half (56.2 percent) were not at all interested in having a bank account.”

Some maintain that a CBDC should replace cash even if cash is preferred by some consumers. They usually point to cash usage among criminals and tax cheats, noting that a CBDC might prevent these undesirable transactions. Of course, replacing cash with a CBDC would also likely reduce financial privacy for law-abiding citizens, as well. The public policy question, therefore, is whether the gain from reducing crime and tax evasion warrants the loss of financial privacy.

A recent New York Times article by Eswar Prasad would seem to suggest we need not worry much about that tradeoff. “The end of cash is on the horizon,” Prasad writes. If a cashless future will soon be upon us, we will suffer the loss of financial privacy regardless of whether the government launches a CBDC. Why not also reap the benefits by introducing a CBDC? Indeed, failing to launch a CBDC “could be a lost opportunity.”

Consider me a skeptic. Predictions of our cashless future have been made for decades. And, despite huge advances in digital payments, currency in circulation continues to rise. In per capita terms, currency in circulation has increased from around $2,116 in January 2000 to $5,461 in January 2020. It accelerated over the course of the pandemic, to $6,325 in January 2021.

Currency in circulation has also grown as a share of nominal spending. In Q1-2000, it was just 5.7%. It was 8.4% in Q1-2020. In Q1-2021, it was 9.5%.

Perhaps these trends will reverse. But it seems more likely that the reports of the forthcoming death of cash have been greatly exaggerated––that is, so long as the government doesn’t kill it.

The post Will Cash Soon Be Obsolete? was first published by the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER), and is republished here with permission. Please support their efforts.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button